NYC: Christmas Eve Buffet Lunch or Dinner Harbor Cruise

An Honest Look at the NYC Christmas Eve Harbor Cruise

This Christmas Eve, thousands of visitors and locals alike seek out ways to mark the holiday in a special way. One popular option is a harbor cruise that combines sightseeing, seasonal dining, and holiday cheer. The experience we review here is operated by City Cruises, offering a buffet lunch or dinner aboard the Spirit of New York, with panoramic views of Manhattan’s iconic skyline, the Statue of Liberty, and more.

What we particularly appreciate about this cruise is its ability to blend beautiful scenery with festive ambiance—imagine dining on a holiday-themed yacht while floating past some of New York’s most famous landmarks. The added touches like a live DJ and seasonal décor make it feel special without going overboard.

A couple of considerations to keep in mind: the price point is around $198 per person, which, while not cheap, includes a 3-course meal, entertainment, and the chance to see the city from the water. Some travelers noted that the group size is manageable, but the experience is more about the ambiance and views than a deeply personalized tour. This cruise is best suited for those looking to combine sightseeing with a festive dining experience—ideal for couples, families, or groups of friends wanting a memorable holiday in New York.

Key Points

• Stunning skyline views: You’ll see Manhattan from the water, with landmarks like the Empire State Building, Brooklyn Bridge, and Statue of Liberty.
• Festive atmosphere: Holiday décor, seasonal music, and a lively DJ create a joyful Christmas vibe.
• Quality dining: A 3-course buffet featuring seasonal favorites, served at a reserved, climate-controlled table.
• Photo opportunities: Up-close views of the Statue of Liberty and the city skyline make for memorable photo moments.
• Comfort and convenience: Fully enclosed dining areas and outdoor decks offer options depending on the weather.
• Good value for the experience: Combination of scenery, dining, and entertainment at a fixed price.

A Detailed Breakdown of the Experience

Departure and Boarding

Your journey begins at Chelsea Piers, a central and easily accessible location in Manhattan. Boarding the Spirit of New York, guests are welcomed into a climate-controlled dining room with large windows offering panoramic views. The ship’s décor is geared up for the holiday season, with twinkling lights, ornaments, and festive touches that instantly set a cheerful mood.

The Itinerary and What to Expect

The cruise lasts about 2.5 hours for the dinner option (or 2 hours for lunch), during which you’ll cruise past some of NYC’s most recognizable sights on both the Hudson and East Rivers. As you glide past the Empire State Building, Chrysler Building, One World Trade Center, and the Vessel at Hudson Yards, you’ll get an impressive perspective of Manhattan’s skyline.

One of the highlights is a close-up view of the Statue of Liberty, where you can easily grab your camera—many guests shared that the photo ops are exceptional, especially with the city’s lights flickering in the background. Some reviewers, like Jean Michel, praised the experience, saying, “Tout est très bien,” highlighting the overall smoothness and quality.

Dining Experience

The meal is a seasonally inspired 3-course buffet, served at your reserved table. Think traditional holiday flavors with a New York twist—from roasted meats to seasonal vegetables and festive desserts. The buffet setup allows you to mingle and enjoy your meal without feeling rushed, and the all-you-can-drink option for coffee, tea, and iced tea is included, which adds to the relaxing atmosphere.

Some reviews noted the quality and presentation of the food as being quite good for a cruise setting, with one traveler mentioning the “all the seasonal favorites” made the meal feel hearty and comforting amidst the winter voyage.

Entertainment and Atmosphere

A live DJ elevates the mood with holiday tunes, dance beats, and classic favorites. Guests are encouraged to dance and enjoy the lively environment, with some reviewers suggesting that the music and décor make it feel more like a holiday party than a typical sightseeing cruise. Sophie, for example, remarked that “a little extra time even while docked would make the evening even better,” emphasizing the festive atmosphere.

Outdoor and Indoor Spaces

The Spirit of New York has both enclosed interior decks and large outdoor open-air rooftops—perfect for viewing the city lights if the weather permits. Guests can stroll around the decks or stay cozy inside while still enjoying the vistas through the large windows. Weather isn’t usually a concern in December, thanks to the climate-controlled areas, but the outdoor decks are a great option if you’re bundled up and want a more immersive experience.

Additional Touches

While alcoholic beverages are available for purchase, the cruise includes unlimited coffee, tea, and iced tea, which guests appreciated. Some reviews mentioned that the bar selection was good, with seasonal cocktails adding to the holiday spirit.

Group Size and Accessibility

The cruise typically hosts a manageable number of guests, ensuring a relaxed and enjoyable environment. It’s wheelchair accessible and designed to accommodate various needs, which is a big plus for those with mobility concerns.

Analyzing the Price and Overall Value

At $198 per person, this cruise isn’t the most budget-friendly holiday outing in New York. However, when you factor in the all-inclusive nature—a 3-course buffet, entertainment, scenic views, and the unique experience of celebrating Christmas Eve on the water—the cost can be justified for many travelers seeking something memorable.

Reviewers have commented on the quality of the views and the festive ambiance as being worth the price. One guest mentioned that the extra hour at dock during New Year’s Eve would have been ideal, suggesting that longer experiences might enhance value, but overall, the cruise offers a solid package that combines sightseeing with holiday cheer.

Who Will Love This Experience?

This cruise is perfect for couples wanting a romantic holiday evening, families with kids looking for a festive outing, or groups of friends eager to celebrate together. It’s also a good choice for visitors who want to experience NYC from the water during the holidays, especially with the seasonal décor and entertainment making it more than just a sightseeing trip.

Final Thoughts: Is This Cruise Worth It?

If you’re seeking a scenic, festive, and well-organized way to celebrate Christmas Eve, this harbor cruise delivers on all fronts. The breathtaking views of Manhattan’s skyline combined with a delicious seasonal meal and lively holiday music create a memorable evening. It’s a smooth, comfortable experience that offers good value, especially for those wanting to avoid the hustle of crowded restaurants or busy sightseeing tours.

That said, it’s not a budget option, and if you’re after a more intimate or personalized experience, you might find this cruise a bit commercial. But for families, couples, or groups looking for a unique holiday activity that blends scenery, celebration, and good food, it’s a solid choice.

FAQ

Is this cruise suitable for children?
Yes, children are welcome, and infants under 2 are free if you select the appropriate ticket option. It’s a family-friendly way to celebrate.

Does the cruise operate rain or shine?
The interior dining areas are fully enclosed, so you’ll stay dry and warm regardless of the weather. Outdoor decks are available if the weather permits.

Are alcoholic drinks included?
No, alcoholic beverages are available for purchase at the bar. The cruise includes unlimited coffee, tea, and iced tea.

What is the duration of the cruise?
The dinner cruise lasts about 2.5 hours, while the lunch cruise is around 2 hours. Check availability for specific start times.

Can I reserve a specific seating?
Reservations are for a reserved private table in the dining room, but the experience is designed for group dining, so specific seat requests are not guaranteed.

Is the cruise accessible for guests with mobility issues?
Yes, the cruise is wheelchair accessible, and the venue is designed to accommodate a range of mobility needs.

What landmarks will I see?
Expect to cruise past the Empire State Building, Chrysler Building, One World Trade Center, Brooklyn Bridge, Manhattan Bridge, South Street Seaport, and a close-up of the Statue of Liberty.

Can I take photos during the cruise?
Absolutely. The large windows and outdoor decks provide excellent photo opportunities, especially of the Statue of Liberty and skyline.

Is there a dress code?
Smart casual is recommended. Dress warmly in winter, especially if you plan to spend time outside on the decks.

This holiday cruise offers a delightful blend of NYC sightseeing, festive cheer, and delicious food. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just want a different way to enjoy Christmas Eve, it’s an experience that’s likely to leave you with lasting memories of the city’s winter magic.