St. Marys Murder, Mayhem, and Martinis Walking Tour

Exploring a small town like St. Marys, Georgia through a walking tour focused on its sinister stories and intriguing architecture offers a unique way to connect with its past and present. This particular experience, offered by Molly’s Old South Tours, weaves together tales of real murders, historic landmarks, and local legends—all wrapped up with the fun of ending at a lively saloon with discounted drinks. With a perfect 5-star rating based on 8 reviews, it’s clear that many visitors find this tour both entertaining and insightful.

One of the standout features? The blend of historical storytelling and lively atmosphere. You won’t just listen to dry facts; instead, each stop is rich with colorful anecdotes, some dating back more than two centuries. Plus, the exclusive Happy Hour at Seagles Saloon offers a laid-back way to unwind after a walk filled with spooky tales and stunning views. However, a potential consideration is that this tour lasts just over an hour—so if you’re craving a deep dive into every detail, you might find it a bit brisk.

This tour is a great fit for history buffs, fans of true crime, or anyone who enjoys a mix of education and entertainment. It’s particularly appealing if you want a lighthearted, short activity that adds flavor to your time in St. Marys without requiring a full day or intense physical effort.

Key Points

• History with a twist: The tour combines architectural appreciation with stories of murders and mayhem.
• Authentic storytelling: Led by knowledgeable guides, like Molly, who bring local legends vividly to life.
• Short and sweet: At around 1 hour 15 minutes, it’s perfect for a quick, engaging activity.
• Exclusive drink discounts: End the tour with happy hour prices at Seagles Saloon for a relaxed finish.
• Free stops: All stops are free to enter, focusing on storytelling outside of the architecture, which adds to the budget-friendly appeal.
• Great reviews: Consistently high ratings suggest a well-organized, enjoyable experience.

The Itinerary: A Closer Look

Stop 1: Archibald Clark House
This is the oldest house in St. Marys, notable for its impressive architecture. Beyond its aesthetic appeal, it’s linked to the British occupation during the War of 1812, where its owner, Archibald Clark, was involved in episodes of murder and mayhem. Visitors love this stop for its historical significance and the way the guide ties in fascinating stories about early 19th-century conflict. One reviewer mentions, “Molly did a great job with perfect timing and loads of information,” indicating the storytelling skill involved.

Stop 2: First Presbyterian Church
Here, you’ll learn about a bizarre incident from the early 1800s involving a horse stuck in the church’s bell tower—an oddly memorable story. The guide’s recounting keeps the audience engaged, and the humorous mystery of “who put it there” adds a light touch to the visit. It’s a quick 10-minute stop, making it a good palate cleanser between more intense tales.

Stop 3: Orange Hall Gilman Cultural Center
This Greek Revival mansion is more than just pretty architecture. It’s connected to Daniel McGirt, a Revolutionary War turncoat turned infamous bandit. Visitors appreciate how the guide weaves tales of betrayal, crime, and the region’s turbulent past into this stop, making it more than just a photo opportunity.

Stop 4: 213 Osborne Street
This 1830s home marks a tragic story—the murder of Thomas Hardee. His story involves a stubborn denial of a romantic opportunity, which ultimately led to his death. The emotional weight of this tale adds depth to the walk. Reviewers note how the storytelling keeps the history alive, with one saying, “We learned so much about St. Marys.”

Stop 5: 220 Osborne Street
Once a medical clinic for the Gilman Paper Company, this Victorian home has a darker history. It’s linked to a covert assassination plot involving high-ranking company members—one of the more surprising stories on the tour. This stop lasts 15 minutes, giving enough space to appreciate the building and the narrative.

Stop 6: Spencer House Inn by Brehm
This charming bed & breakfast features “haint” blue porch ceilings, a color traditionally used to ward off ghosts in the South. The guide explains the hauntingly practical tradition, adding cultural depth and a dash of ghostly intrigue to the experience.

Stop 7: St. Marys Submarine Museum
Situated on land once owned by John Houstoun McIntosh, this location ties into the Patriot War of 1812, when locals caused chaos trying to take Florida from Spain. The museum’s outside offers the perfect setting for stories of local rebellion and daring raids that keep history lively and tangible.

Stop 8: Waterfront and Market
The tour concludes with a stroll along the picturesque riverfront, where you’ll hear about a more recent murder, a story that surprises given the peaceful scenery. This last stop leaves visitors with a balanced mix of scenic beauty and captivating crime stories.

The Happy Hour Finale at Seagles Saloon

After the walking portion, everyone heads to Seagles Saloon, where exclusive Happy Hour-priced drinks await. Many reviews praise this as a perfect way to relax and reflect on the stories heard. The relaxed atmosphere, combined with the chance to chat with other guests, adds a social element to the experience. The 10-minute duration ensures you’re not rushed, but still able to unwind comfortably.

Practical Details and Value

At $24 per person, this tour offers remarkable value considering the breadth of stories and the engaging guide. All stops are free to access, and the focus on storytelling means no extra costs—aside from optional drinks. The tour’s mobile ticket system makes it easy to join, with the meeting point conveniently located at 400 Osborne Street.

The maximum group size of 25 ensures a personal feel, and the tour is suitable for most travelers, including service animals. It runs most days, with bookings typically made 26 days in advance, reflecting strong interest and trust in the experience.

While the tour is brief, it packs enough intrigue and local lore to satisfy those interested in Southern history, true crime tales, or just a fun, ghost-story vibe. The weather can affect plans—cancellation due to poor weather is possible, but full refunds or rescheduling are offered.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This experience is ideal for travelers who appreciate short, engaging activities that combine history, storytelling, and a bit of spooky fun. It suits those looking for a lighthearted, culturally enriching outing without the need for extensive walking or time commitment. It’s especially appealing if you enjoy local legends and authentic storytelling, and want a memorable way to experience St. Marys beyond typical sightseeing.

Final Thoughts

The St. Marys Murder, Mayhem, and Martinis Walking Tour offers a well-balanced mix of history, intrigue, and entertainment. For just $24, you’ll gain insights into the town’s darker stories, admire historic architecture, and enjoy a relaxed social ending with exclusive drinks. With glowing reviews praising the storytelling and the fun atmosphere, it’s clear that this experience hits the mark for many visitors.

If you’re eager for a short but captivating adventure that reveals the character of St. Marys through tales of crime and charm, this tour is a solid choice. It’s perfect for those who want a fun, fact-filled outing with a touch of ghostly flair and a generous dash of southern storytelling charm.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for children?
Most travelers can participate, but the stories are adult-themed, involving murder and mayhem, so discretion is advised for younger children.

How long does the tour last?
The walking tour takes approximately 1 hour 15 minutes, making it a compact but engaging activity.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at 400 Osborne Street and ends outside Seagles Restaurant at 105 Osborne Street, where Happy Hour drinks are available.

Are drinks included?
No, alcoholic beverages are not included; the tour offers discounts at the saloon for participants aged 18 and over.

Can I cancel if I change my mind?
Yes, full refunds are available if you cancel at least 24 hours before the start date.

What’s the best way to prepare?
Wear comfortable shoes for walking and bring some curiosity about local stories and history.

Is this tour good for history buffs?
Absolutely—each stop ties into real historical events, local legends, and intriguing stories.

What makes this tour stand out?
The combination of authentic stories, beautiful architecture, and a lively social finish at a historic saloon.

Are there any physical limitations?
The tour is mostly walking and standing, suitable for most, but check your mobility needs especially in case of bad weather or weather-related delays.

To sum it up, the St. Marys Murder, Mayhem, and Martinis Walking Tour delivers a fun, engaging way to explore this charming town’s darker side. Its blend of history, local legends, and social relaxation makes it an experience worth considering for anyone visiting St. Marys who wants to add a little intrigue to their trip.