South Maui: Gilligans’ Island Luau with Dinner and Drinks

Planning a night out in Maui that offers a taste of Polynesian culture, lively entertainment, and a satisfying meal? Gilligans’ Island Luau in Kihei delivers just that. This experience is a cozy, locally owned event that promises an engaging show, genuine storytelling, and a welcoming atmosphere—perfect for travelers seeking an authentic taste of Hawaii without the overwhelming crowds.

What we really appreciate about this luau is its intimate setting. Unlike some of the larger, commercial luaus, Gilligans keeps the experience personal, with every seat offering a great view. Plus, the inclusion of an open bar, a hearty buffet, and audience participation makes it feel like a special night out rather than just another tourist trap.

One thing to keep in mind is that the show is performed on a flat stage, which some visitors note makes it harder to see the dancers’ full movements, especially if seated at the back. For those who prioritize a clear view of the performances, arriving early or requesting a high-top table might be wise. This tour suits those who want a relaxed yet culturally rich evening that combines entertainment, food, and drinks in a manageable two-and-a-half-hour format—ideal for families, couples, and solo travelers alike.

Key Points

• Authentic and Intimate: Smaller, locally-run luau with a personal touch and great views from every seat.
• Varied Polynesian Show: Includes storytelling, traditional dances, music, and a fiery finale featuring a fire knife.
• Delicious Buffet: Offers a wide selection of Hawaiian favorites, with room for everyone’s tastes.
• Open Bar: All-you-can-drink includes tropical drinks, wine, beer, and non-alcoholic beverages.
• Location Advantage: Uniquely situated on the Maui Nui Golf Course, offering a scenic backdrop with sunset views.
• Authentic Audience Participation: Guests might even get the chance to join parts of the show, making it memorable.

A Deep Dive into the Maui Luau Experience

The Setting and Location

Gilligans’ Island Luau is located on the Maui Nui Golf Course in Kihei, making it a convenient choice for visitors staying in South Maui. The venue’s size is intentionally kept small to preserve intimacy, which most reviews highlight as a major plus. Unlike larger, more commercial luaus, this spot feels like a friendly gathering—think of it as a Polynesian cultural night hosted by good friends rather than a big staged event.

Guests are welcomed warmly by performers who help seat everyone, adding a personal touch from the start. Sitting at a high-top table or arriving early is recommended for better views—especially since some reviewers mention the show is performed on a flat stage, which can make it tricky to see the dancers’ full movements from the back.

The Show: More Than Just Dancing

The heart of the evening is the Polynesian performance, which takes you on a voyage through different islands’ cultures—from Hawaii to Tahiti to New Zealand. The performers are praised for their energy and skill, with several reviews mentioning the “incredible” dancers and talented musicians. The show includes storytelling, traditional dances, and a lively drum performance, with a fiery finale performed by a Samoan fire dancer that leaves audiences mesmerized.

Several reviewers appreciated the interactive element, noting that some guests were invited to participate in parts of the show. This adds a layer of fun and engagement, making the experience feel very personal rather than a passive viewing.

Dining: A Generous Hawaiian Buffet

The buffet is another highlight—covering a wide variety of Hawaiian staples like kalua pork, teriyaki chicken, mahi mahi with lemon dill cream, and poi. The inclusion of panko-crusted mahi mahi and Hawaiian sweet rolls with honey butter makes for a satisfying meal, with reviewers praising the generous portions and tasty flavors.

One review mentioned that the food was “good, but nothing special,” while others found it to be “delicious” and well-prepared. The buffet also features local favorites like lomi lomi salmon, mac salad, and sweet potatoes, giving guests a true taste of Hawaiian cuisine.

Drinks and Atmosphere

All drinks are included, with a well-stocked open bar featuring tropical cocktails, wine, beer, and non-alcoholic options. Guests report the drinks are “tasty” and plentiful, adding to the relaxed, festive vibe of the night. The friendly servers keep the drinks coming, and the atmosphere is lively yet cozy.

Authenticity and Audience Experience

Multiple reviews highlight the authentic atmosphere of the event, with performers sharing stories and explaining the musical instruments used. The show’s focus on storytelling and cultural education distinguishes it from more commercialized luaus, making it a great choice for travelers eager to learn and experience Hawaii’s traditions firsthand.

Value for Money

At $166 per person, the price is reasonable considering the all-you-can-eat buffet and open bar, along with high-quality entertainment. Several reviewers state that it offers good value, especially for those who want an immersive experience without the crowds or hefty price tags of larger luaus. The smaller size and personalized service add to the perception of getting more for your money.

What We Think Could Be Improved

A common critique relates to the stage setup. Since performances are on a flat stage, some guests find it difficult to see the full dance movements, especially if seated at the back. Arriving early or requesting a high-top table can mitigate this. A few reviewers also mentioned that the food, while good, is not exceptional—so if you’re craving gourmet cuisine, this might not be the top priority.

Plus, because the venue is small, it sells out quickly, so early reservations are advised.

Who Will Love This Experience?

Travelers seeking an authentic, intimate Polynesian night will find Gilligans’ Island Luau a delightful choice. It’s perfect for those wanting to avoid large crowds but still enjoy a lively show, tasty food, and unlimited drinks. Families with children, couples, or solo adventurers who appreciate storytelling and cultural education will also appreciate the personal, relaxed vibe.

If you’re looking for a noteworthy cultural event that balances entertainment and education, this luau ticks those boxes without feeling overly commercial. For travelers on a budget, it offers good value, especially considering the inclusions.

The Sum Up: Is Gilligans’ Island Luau Worth It?

This luau provides an engaging, authentic experience that combines Polynesian storytelling, energetic performances, and a hearty Hawaiian buffet—delivered in a cozy, personal setting. The small venue and focus on audience interaction make it stand out from larger, more impersonal luaus, giving guests a more genuine taste of Hawaiian culture.

If you’re after a lively show with talented dancers and musicians, coupled with unlimited drinks and tasty local fare, this is a strong choice. It’s particularly well-suited for those who value up-close performances and want to avoid the crowds typical of bigger luaus.

For travelers craving a cultural highlight with a relaxed atmosphere, reasonable price, and friendly hosts, Gilligans’ Island Luau offers a memorable Maui evening. Just remember to reserve early to claim your preferred spot and enjoy the full experience.

FAQ

Is the show suitable for children?
Yes, the show is family-friendly, with audience participation and lively performances suitable for all ages.

How long does the luau last?
The entire experience lasts approximately 2.5 hours, including dinner and the show.

Are drinks really unlimited?
Yes, with your ticket, you can enjoy all the beverages from the open bar, including tropical drinks, wine, beer, and non-alcoholic options.

Is there any special seating or VIP options?
While the venue is small and seats are first-come, first-served, many guests recommend arriving early or requesting a high-top table for better views.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, reservations are refundable if canceled up to 24 hours in advance.

Is the venue wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the luau is wheelchair accessible, ensuring all guests can enjoy the experience.

In summary, Gilligans’ Island Luau offers a well-rounded night of Polynesian culture, great food, and fun entertainment in a friendly, intimate setting. Perfect for those who want a genuine taste of Hawaii without the overwhelming crowds or high prices often associated with larger luaus. It’s a memorable, engaging way to spend an evening on Maui.