Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish

Visiting Key West and considering a day out on the water? If catching big fish and enjoying the open sea appeals to you, the Key West Deep Sea Fishing tour with Corsair 2 Sportfishing might be just what you’re after. As someone who’s seen many fishing excursions, I can tell you this one has a lot of potential for a memorable day, especially if you love the thrill of reeling in a big catch.

What caught my attention is the boat’s impressive setup — outfitted with modern electronics, outriggers, a fighting chair, and even private restrooms and a kitchen. These features point to a well-maintained vessel designed for comfort and success. Plus, with reviews highlighting friendly crews and abundant fish, it’s clear this tour offers genuine value. That said, it’s not a cheap outing, so understanding what you’re really paying for helps you decide if it’s right for your trip.

One consideration: the boat itself is quite old, according to some reviews, which might matter if your priority is a pristine, ultra-modern vessel. But for most, the experience and catch outweigh that detail. This tour is best suited for those who love fishing, enjoy being on the water, and are ready for a private, tailored experience. It’s most appealing to serious anglers or those seeking a special adventure at sea.

Key Points

• The tour offers a private charter for up to six anglers, ideal for families or small groups seeking exclusivity.
• Depths up to 18 miles offshore mean chances to reel in mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, and other big fish.
• Multiple duration options—half, three-quarter, or full-day—allow flexibility based on your schedule.
• Modern equipment and safety gear ensure a confident and successful fishing experience.
• The boat includes comfort features like restrooms, a kitchen, beds, air conditioning, and a flybridge.
• The cost of $950 per group is a fair value considering the boat’s amenities, equipment, and the personalized service.

An In-Depth Look at the Experience

The Starting Point and Logistics

This tour begins at 5950 Peninsular Ave, Key West. Located conveniently, it’s accessible near public transportation, making it easy to find without fuss. Confirmations are quick, and the tour is private—your group alone on the boat, which enhances both comfort and exclusivity.

What’s Included and What’s Not

Bottled water is provided, keeping everyone hydrated during the trip. Alcoholic beverages are not included — so if you’re planning to celebrate with a cold one, you’ll need to bring your own. Remember, bringing bananas is discouraged—some reviewers have noted this is a thing, so it’s worth respecting the crew’s guidelines.

The Boat and Its Features

The vessel itself is equipped to handle a full day on the water comfortably. It boasts state-of-the-art navigational electronics, outriggers for casting, a fighting chair for serious angling, and a live bait tank. These features mean you’re well-positioned to hunt big fish, and the boat’s ice boxes keep your catch fresh.

Onboard comforts are surprisingly good: two private restrooms, a kitchen, beds, and air conditioning. The flybridge offers excellent views, so even non-anglers or those taking a break can enjoy the scenery. Some reviews mentioned the boat’s age—over 40 years old—but it appears to be well-maintained and functional.

The Fishing Itinerary

Most trips are around four hours but can be extended to half, three-quarter, or full days. You’ll venture up to 18 miles offshore, where the deep sea meets reef, providing a variety of fishing opportunities. Expect to target mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, and other species known for their fighting spirit — perfect for anglers looking for a challenge.

The Crew and Service

Reviewers highlight the crew’s friendliness, professionalism, and dedication. Captain Jeff and Christian receive praise for their responsiveness and ability to put clients on fish. The mate’s hard work and guidance help maximize your chances, making the experience as enjoyable as it is successful.

Tom_K sums it up: “The crew was great! The Captain put us on the fish and the Mate worked hard. Both are nice guys who made sure we had a fun day.” That personal touch makes a huge difference, especially for those new to fishing or looking for a relaxed, friendly vibe.

The Catch and the Memories

Many guests report catching multiple fish early in the trip, sometimes hooking four or five at once. Christian’s filleting skills mean your catch can be prepared for dinner, adding a tasty and satisfying bonus to the day. Michelle_M notes, “We caught many fish in the first couple of hours and hooked four basically at the same time!”

Potential Drawbacks

While reviews are overwhelmingly positive, some mention the boat’s age as a concern. Ron_C pointed out that the vessel looked tired and showed signs of wear. However, no one seemed to report safety issues or discomfort—just a reminder that this is a well-used fishing boat, not a brand-new yacht.

Weather can impact the trip; the tour requires good conditions to proceed. Cancellations due to poor weather are fully refunded, which offers peace of mind. It’s wise to book with some flexibility if your schedule allows.

Value for Money

At $950 for up to six people, the tour offers a private, all-inclusive experience with equipment, safety gear, and onboard amenities. Considering the personalized service, the chance to fish offshore, and the potential to catch prized species, many will find this to be a worthwhile expense. For anglers, it’s a chance to fish in a professional setting with a good chance of success.

Who Should Book This Tour?

If you’re seeking a private deep-sea fishing adventure with a focus on big game species, this tour is a strong choice. It’s ideal for small groups or families who want personalized attention and comfort on the water. Serious anglers will appreciate the modern equipment and knowledgeable crew, while casual fishers can enjoy the thrill of the chase. It’s also suitable for those wanting a memorable outdoor experience in Key West, especially if they value comfort and quality gear.

Best for: Small groups, fishing enthusiasts, families, or anyone looking for a high-quality, private offshore fishing trip.

Final Thoughts

This Key West deep sea fishing experience offers a lot for the price — from a well-equipped boat and experienced crew to the thrill of catching prime fish species. The private setting ensures your group gets personalized attention, and the onboard amenities add comfort to an active day on the water. While the boat’s age might give some pause, most guests seem to find the overall experience far outweighs that detail.

Whether you’re hoping to reel in mahi mahi for dinner or simply want the excitement of battling a big fish, this tour delivers. It’s best suited for those who appreciate a combination of comfort, professionalism, and genuine fishing success. For a special day out in Key West, it’s hard to beat.

FAQ

Is this a private tour?
Yes, it’s a private experience, so only your group participates.

What’s included in the price?
Bottled water is provided. The trip includes the boat, equipment, and crew, but alcoholic beverages are not included.

How long is the trip?
The typical duration is approximately four hours, with options to extend to half, 3/4, or full-day trips.

Where do I meet the boat?
At 5950 Peninsular Ave, Key West. The location is accessible near public transportation.

Can I bring food or drinks?
You can bring your own drinks, but alcohol is not supplied. Respect the crew’s request not to bring bananas.

What fish can I expect to catch?
Targets include mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, and other big fish species.

Is the boat well-maintained?
The boat is over 40 years old, but reviews suggest it is well-kept and equipped for a successful trip.

What weather conditions are needed?
Good weather is required. If the weather turns poor, the trip will be canceled and fully refunded.

Can beginners join?
Most travelers can participate, regardless of experience. The crew is helpful, making it suitable for first-timers.

How far offshore will we go?
Up to 18 miles offshore, where you’ll find the best fishing opportunities.

Whether you’re after a fun family adventure or a serious angling expedition, this Key West deep sea fishing tour provides a well-rounded, memorable experience. Prepare for a day of excitement, camaraderie, and hopefully, a hefty catch.