Before Stonewall: Secret Gay History of NYC

Imagine strolling through Greenwich Village, a neighborhood famous for its bohemian vibe and vibrant LGBTQ+ history, and uncovering stories that many travelers and even locals don’t know. That’s exactly what a 2-hour walking tour titled “Before Stonewall: Secret Gay History of NYC” offers. It’s a fascinating journey into the lives of queer people long before the Stonewall Riots changed everything, revealing a city that has been intertwined with LGBTQ+ life from its founding.

What makes this tour stand out? First, it’s a chance to learn about LGBTQ+ icons and unsung pioneers who shaped New York’s identity. Second, the focus on hidden sites and stories makes it a more intimate, authentic experience. That said, with a price of $39 per person, you’re paying for a well-curated education rather than a flashy spectacle. It’s best suited for those curious about history, social justice, or anyone wanting a richer context for NYC’s queer culture.

One thing to keep in mind: the tour involves a moderate amount of walking over two hours, so comfortable shoes are a must. It’s accessible for most, but not ideal for children under 10. If you’re eager to see Greenwich Village through a new lens, this tour offers a compelling and respectful look into a vibrant but often overlooked past.

Key Points

• In-depth historical stories of LGBTQ+ figures and sites before Stonewall.
• Exploration of Greenwich Village, NoHo, and East Village neighborhoods.
• Insight into queer artists, radicals, and pioneers like Walt Whitman, Murray Hall, and others.
• Stories of resistance, nightlife, and social change including the 1966 Sip-In.
• Focus on lesser-known figures such as Mary Jones and Lord Cornbury.
• Accessible, engaging guide with a 4.6-star rating based on visitor reviews.

You can check availability for your dates here:

What to Expect from the Tour

This walking tour offers a thoughtful, engaging look into New York City’s LGBTQ+ past, long before the iconic 1969 Stonewall Riots. Led by an expert LGBTQ+ historian, the guide shares stories that are often not part of mainstream history books. You’ll walk through historic neighborhoods and visit key sites that have played pivotal roles in queer life.

The Itinerary in Detail

Starting Point: The tour begins on the corner of Bleeker Street and Broadway, right in front of Van Leeuwen Ice Cream. From there, expect a walk through Greenwich Village, often called America’s first Bohemian playground. The guide will point out buildings and landmarks while sharing stories about their significance.

Historical Figures & Hidden Sites: The tour highlights figures like Mary Jones (Peter Sewally), a 19th-century Black transgender sex worker whose story challenges conventional narratives. You’ll also learn about Lord Cornbury, a colonial governor rumored to have ruled in drag—an example of how queer identities have long been part of political and social life.

LGBTQ+ Pioneers and Resistance: You’ll hear about Murray Hall, a trans man who lived undetected for decades as a respected city politician, and about the Mob’s profit off queer nightlife, which paints a picture of how unconventional lifestyles were both celebrated and exploited. The 1966 Sip-In at Julius bar, a key moment of activism fighting for gay rights, will also be part of the story.

Lesbian Bars and Social Spaces: The guide will take you past historic lesbian bars like the Pony Stable Inn and Eves Hangout, giving you a sense of how queer communities created their own spaces, often in secret or in the face of rejection.

Public Parks and Spaces: You’ll see parks and public areas that served as safe havens for queer connection—before laws and societal norms imposed restrictions. The stories reveal both the city’s enabling role and its capacity for punishment.

The Experience & Atmosphere

Reviews frequently mention the “engaging, knowledgeable guide” who makes complex history accessible and compelling. The stories are often surprising, like the mention of romantic letters between Alexander Hamilton and John Laurens, which adds a layer of depth and humanizes these historical figures.

The tour balances informative storytelling with visual clues, so expect to walk through streets that echo past eras. The cost of $39 seems fair considering the insight and exclusive access to hidden sites you gain. Many reviewers praise the quality of the storytelling and the passion of the guide, often calling it a “powerful” eye-opener.

Practical Considerations

• Duration: 2 hours of moderate walking, so wear comfortable shoes.
• Meeting Point: Corner of Bleeker Street and Broadway—easy to find, right in the heart of vibrant Greenwich Village.
• Weather: Operates rain or shine, so bring an umbrella or raincoat as needed.
• Accessibility: The tour is wheelchair accessible, making it inclusive for most visitors.
• Not suitable for children under 10—the stories and themes are geared toward older audiences.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Value for Travelers

For a modest price, this tour offers a rare window into a hidden universe of New York’s LGBTQ+ history. You’ll leave with a deeper understanding of how queer life has shaped and been shaped by the city’s neighborhoods. It’s ideal for history buffs, LGBTQ+ allies, or those interested in social justice stories.

If you’re looking to go beyond the typical sightseeing checklist and understand the people and places that have been part of NYC’s fabric for generations, this tour brings that past vividly to life. And because it’s a relatively short commitment — just two hours — it fits well into a busy sightseeing day.

Final Thoughts: Who Should Take This Tour?

This walk is best for travelers who value authentic stories over touristy clichés. It’s particularly suited for those who want to connect with the city’s LGBTQ+ roots in a respectful, insightful way. Perfect for history enthusiasts, socially conscious travelers, or anyone curious about the hidden stories that shaped New York City’s culture.

If you’re eager to see Greenwich Village through a different lens, learn about pioneers and radicals who challenged norms, and appreciate the city’s long-standing LGBTQ+ presence, this tour delivers a worthwhile experience. It’s a chance to uncover the city’s less polished, more personal stories—the kind that often get lost in mainstream narratives.

FAQ

How long is the tour?
It lasts approximately 2 hours, covering a moderate amount of walking through key neighborhoods.

What is the meeting point?
The tour begins at the corner of Bleeker Street and Broadway, in front of Van Leeuwen Ice Cream.

Is the tour accessible for wheelchair users?
Yes, the tour is wheelchair accessible, making it easier for more people to join and explore.

What should I wear?
Comfortable shoes are recommended because of the walking involved. Bring sunscreen and water, especially in warmer weather.

Does the tour operate rain or shine?
Yes, it goes ahead regardless of weather, so dress accordingly.

Is it suitable for children?
It’s not recommended for children under 10 due to the mature themes and complexity of stories.

What’s included in the price?
The tour includes a guided experience and access to hidden historical sites. Food, drinks, and transportation are not included.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

Is there a limit on when I can book?
You can reserve your spot now and pay later, offering flexibility if your plans are uncertain.

This tour isn’t just about learning facts; it’s an opportunity to see how LGBTQ+ lives have always been woven into the fabric of New York City. For those ready to peel back a layer of history and appreciate the city’s longstanding queer roots, it’s a compelling choice worth considering.

You can check availability for your dates here: More Great Tours Nearby