Torrid Tales Two More True Crime in St. Augustine

A Closer Look at Torrid Tales Two More True Crime in St. Augustine

If you’re drawn to the thrill of true crime stories and enjoy exploring historic streets with a twist, this Torrid Tales tour offers a rare peek into the darker side of St. Augustine. Unlike typical sightseeing jaunts, this 90-minute journey takes you along the very spots where some tragic or mysterious events unfolded, making history feel a little more real and personal.

What makes this tour especially appealing is its focus on lesser-known cases and its commitment to walking in the victims’ footsteps—sometimes right where they fell. Plus, at just $30 per person, it provides a compelling mix of history, mystery, and local storytelling, all delivered by a licensed, city-certified guide. However, it’s worth noting that with a maximum of 12 travelers, it keeps things intimate but also means you’re part of a small group, which can be a plus or a drawback depending on your preference.

This tour is ideal for true crime enthusiasts or history buffs who enjoy exploring the stories behind the landmarks. If you’re looking for a fun, slightly eerie experience that adds depth to your visit, this could be just the ticket. On the other hand, those expecting a fast-paced or highly polished tour might find it a bit niche. Still, for those curious about the town’s darker chapters, it’s a memorable way to spend an evening.

Key Points

• Unique Perspective: Focuses on lesser-known true crime cases in St. Augustine, making it more than just a typical tour.
• Walking Tour: The entire experience is a walk through historic areas, with stops at notable landmarks.
• Small Group: Limited to a maximum of 12 travelers, ensuring a more personalized experience.
• Authentic Stories: Guided by a licensed and city-certified guide, providing credible narration.
• Price & Duration: At $30 for 1.5 hours, it offers a good value for those interested in dark history.
• Memorable Locations: Stops include places like Ripley’s Bayfront Mini Golf, Bridge Street, Plaza de la Constitución, and Flagler College.

Exploring the Itinerary: What You Can Expect

Start at Ripley’s Bayfront Mini Golf
Your journey begins here, a lively spot with a relaxed vibe. This is where you’ll meet your guide and learn the first case. The location is central, right on the bayfront, which makes for an atmospheric start. As the tour kicks off, you’ll get a quick overview of what’s to come, setting the tone for a night filled with stories of tragedy and mystery. The initial stop is free, so you can settle in without worry about extra costs.

Bridge Street & Marine Street
Next, you’ll walk along streets bustling with nightlife during the day, but at night, these areas reveal a different story. Here, the guide discusses a second case, pointing out specific spots connected to the victim. Expect stories that are not commonly discussed elsewhere, which adds a layer of intrigue. The walk here takes about 20 minutes, with some stops inside or outside various buildings that have historical significance.

Plaza de la Constitución & the Cathedral
Moving to perhaps the most iconic square in St. Augustine, the tour shifts its focus to a case involving the nearby cathedral. This stop is particularly interesting because it ties the crime stories directly to recognizable landmarks. Expect to learn about events that have taken place in this historic square, and how they connect to the local lore. The 15-minute discussion here might include some of the most chilling or fascinating stories.

Flagler College & End near Cordova/ Treasury Streets
As the tour wraps up around the area of Flagler College, the stories become more concentrated in this vicinity. If time allows, the last cases are discussed in or near the college grounds. The tour concludes at or near the parking lot for Flagler College, making it easy for travelers to continue exploring or head back to their accommodations.

The Experience: What Sets It Apart

What makes this tour stand out is its dedication to authenticity. The guide’s license and certification assure you’re getting credible storytelling, not just sensationalized tales. You’ll walk the same streets as the victims, which enhances the emotional impact of the stories. The focus on not widely known cases means you’ll gain insights not typically found in standard guides or tourist pamphlets.

The pace is leisurely enough for questions, making it more interactive than a typical narrated walk. Plus, since the group size is capped at 12, you’re more likely to catch details that might get lost in larger tours.

The stories chosen tend to be darker and more somber, which might not suit everyone. But for those who enjoy a mix of history and mystery, the tour offers a compelling narrative that deepens your understanding of St. Augustine beyond its sunny façade.

Reviews and feedback suggest that the stories are engaging and the guide’s delivery is both credible and personable. One reviewer noted, “We loved the way the stories were connected to the locations we visited. It made it all feel very real.” Others appreciated the quiet, respectful tone when recounting tragic events, which enhances the overall experience.

Value and Practical Considerations

At $30, this tour offers good value for the 1.5-hour experience. You’re paying for a guided walk through some of the city’s more shadowy corners, with stories you might not hear elsewhere. It’s a condensed, focused experience, so if you’re short on time but want a memorable, authentic exploration of St. Augustine’s darker stories, this is a solid choice.

The tour runs at night, starting at 8:30 pm, which adds to the atmosphere—cooler temperatures, quieter streets, and an air of mystery. Remember, it’s a walking tour, so comfortable shoes are recommended. Also, the small group size means plenty of opportunity for questions and interaction.

The experience is weather-dependent, so good weather is a must—if canceled due to rain or storms, a full refund or rescheduling is offered. Gratuities are not included but are customary if you enjoyed the guide’s storytelling.

Who Will Love This Tour?

This tour suits history lovers, true crime fans, and those curious about the darker side of St. Augustine. It’s perfect if you want a more personal, storytelling-focused experience that adds depth to your sightseeing. It’s also ideal for travelers who enjoy evening walks and exploring off-the-beaten-path stories.

However, if you prefer a more lively or comprehensive city tour with historic landmarks and daytime sights, this might not be your best fit. The focus on true crime stories means the tone can be somewhat somber, so it’s better suited for mature audiences.

Final Thoughts

This Torrid Tales tour offers an engaging way to see St. Augustine through the lens of its lesser-known, darker stories. It’s an authentic, small-group experience that combines history, mystery, and local storytelling—perfect for those who want to add a spooky, thought-provoking layer to their visit.

The value for the price is clear: a guided walk through shadowy corners of the city, with credible stories that are not overhyped. The tour’s timing at night enhances the chilling effect and makes it feel more immersive. It’s a wonderful choice for true crime enthusiasts or anyone interested in exploring a different side of this historic city.

If you’re after an honest, balanced, and memorable experience that celebrates St. Augustine’s hidden stories, this tour delivers just that.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this tour suitable for children or only adults?
While most travelers can participate, the dark themes may be more suited to older children or teens. The stories are on the somber side, so discretion is advised.

How long does the tour last?
The tour lasts approximately 1 hour 30 minutes, walking through several key locations in the historic district.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at 111 Avenida Menendez and concludes near the parking lot for Flagler College, around the intersection of Cordova and Treasury Streets.

Is there an additional cost for admission to the sites?
No, all stops are included in the tour price. The locations are viewed from the outside, and no extra tickets are necessary.

What should I wear?
Comfortable walking shoes are recommended, as you’ll be on your feet for about an hour and a half. Dress appropriately for the weather, especially if rain is forecast.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, full refunds are available if you cancel at least 24 hours in advance. Cancellations within 24 hours are not refunded.

Are service animals allowed?
Yes, service animals are permitted during the tour.

To sum it up, this Torrid Tales tour offers a distinctive, authentic glimpse into St. Augustine’s less glamorous history. Its focus on real stories, authentic locations, and a small-group setting makes it a memorable addition for those eager to explore the city’s shadows. Whether you’re a die-hard true crime fan or simply curious about the city’s darker past, this tour provides a uniquely local perspective that few other experiences can match.