St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl

If you’re looking for a way to combine a taste of local nightlife with a dose of spooky history, the St. Augustine True Crime Guided Pub Crawl might just be your cup of tea. Priced at $35 per person, this 2-hour tour takes you through the city’s historic streets, sharing stories of unsolved murders, serial killers, and infamous crimes, all while enjoying drinks at some of the area’s favorite pubs. This isn’t your typical bar hop — it’s an immersive experience that reveals a darker side of this charming, old city.

One thing we really appreciate about this tour is how it manages to strike a balance between engaging storytelling and a relaxed pub environment. The guide, whose insights are a highlight, keeps the atmosphere lively and informative without turning into a nighttime history lecture. However, some travelers have noted that the majority of the time is spent simply visiting bars and enjoying drinks while listening — so if you’re expecting a lot of walking or structured stops, this might feel more like a social gathering with a creepy twist.

This experience suits those with a curious streak, especially fans of true crime, history buffs, or anyone interested in St. Augustine’s lesser-known stories. If you’re after a lively, authentic way to explore the city’s past — with a shot of spirits — this tour could be a memorable addition to your visit.

Key Points

Engaging storytelling combined with local pub visits.
Affordable price point of $35 for a 2-hour experience.
Limited group size ensures personalized attention.
Focus on dark history and unsolved crimes.
Relaxed pace with plenty of time to enjoy drinks and chat.
Good for those interested in local lore but not necessarily looking for a heavy walking tour.

The Breakdown of the Experience

Starting Point: Ghost City Tours Store

Your journey begins at the Ghost City Tours store located at 32 Charlotte St. A friendly guide greets you here, and from the outset, you’ll notice that the focus is on storytelling more than walking. You’ll have a chance to browse the bar menu at Pizalley’s Chianti Room, which is where the tour kicks off. The atmosphere is cozy and casual, making it easy to settle in and get ready for an evening of dark tales. Remember, you’ll need to bring your ID, as the tour involves visiting licensed establishments, and video recording isn’t permitted to keep the privacy and ambiance intact.

The First Stop: Pizalley’s Chianti Room

Here, your guide—whose name might be forgotten in the fog of history but whose stories are sharp—starts with tales of William Darrell Lindsey. He was a serial killer targeting addicts and sex workers between 1983 and 1996. We loved the way the guide painted a vivid picture of Lindsey’s crimes, with details that made you shiver, yet without sensationalizing. It’s a reminder that darker chapters in St. Augustine’s past are woven into its streets and people.

Moving to Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila

Next, the group heads to this lively Mexican eatery, which serves as a backdrop for stories of Father Rene Robert. Known for his charitable work with ex-convicts, his murder remains unsolved, adding a layer of mystery to the city’s history. The atmosphere here is vibrant, and the guide’s storytelling keeps the mood reflective but not overly morbid.

The Oldest Street and Forgotten Tonic

The tour then shifts to Forgotten Tonic, a chic bar on Aviles Street, famous for being the oldest street in the U.S. The murder that took place here on March 2, 1800, is a grisly tale, and you’ll learn about the crime in detail. Reviews note that this stop feels more like a traditional pub experience, where the focus is on conversation and drinks, rather than a structured tour. This is quite typical — some find it more of a social outing with dark stories woven in.

Downtown St. Augustine: Saint George Street & Cathedral Place

Walking through the historic heart of St. Augustine, the guide shares stories of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney’s unsolved murder, along with the murder of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley, a Broadway performer and TV hostess. This part of the tour is about connecting stories to real locations, making the history tangible. You can purchase your drinks here, which adds to the casual vibe, but some have mentioned that the stories are less intense at this point — more about the city’s general lore.

Final Stop: Prohibition Kitchen

The tour wraps up at this vintage gastropub, where you’ll enjoy a final drink and hear a few more stories, rounding out your two hours. It’s a fitting end, bringing the experience full circle with a lively atmosphere to discuss what you’ve just learned.

An Honest Look at the Value

At $35, this tour offers a lot of value for lovers of history, crime stories, and local nightlife. The price includes the guide, who is pivotal in bringing these tales to life and ensuring a steady pace. The experience is intentionally relaxed, with small groups limited to nine participants, making for an intimate setting where questions are welcome.

However, it’s worth noting that food and drinks are not included in the price, so you should budget for those in advance. Also, since the tour involves visiting multiple bars, it’s suitable for those who enjoy socializing and drinking rather than strictly a history-focused experience. The 0.9-mile walk isn’t strenuous, but be prepared for some standing and mild strolling through the historic district.

What Travelers Say

Some reviews pointed out that the majority of the time is spent in pubs, with stories told while guests are sipping drinks. One traveler mentioned, “We were surprised that the majority of the tour was drinking by ourselves in the various bars — we thought the tour would incorporate the bars more.” Others appreciated the intimate group size and the engaging storytelling, which made the dark tales more impactful.

Practical Considerations

• Timing: Check availability for starting times, as they vary.
• Rain or Shine: The tour takes place rain or shine, so dress appropriately.
• Age Restrictions: Not suitable for travelers under 21.
• Duration: Two hours of relaxed, storytelling fun.

Who Would Love This Tour?

If you’re fascinated by true crime stories and enjoy exploring historic cities from a local perspective, this tour offers a unique twist on St. Augustine’s charms. It’s perfect for adults who want to combine a bit of nightlife with dark tales of the city’s past. It’s also a good choice for those who prefer small groups and engaging guides rather than large, bus-style tours.

However, if you’re looking for a highly structured or more active sightseeing experience, this might feel a bit casual. Also, if your interests lean more toward the city’s sunny beaches or family-friendly attractions, this tour’s dark themes might not be your best fit.

Final Thoughts

The St. Augustine True Crime Guided Pub Crawl is a clever way to see the city’s less-glamorous side while enjoying local bars in a casual setting. Its storytelling approach makes history come alive, and the small-group format ensures you won’t feel lost in a crowd. It’s a good choice for curious travelers who love a good story and a cold drink, though it’s best to go in the right mindset — as a fun, slightly spooky social experience rather than a rigorous historical tour.

Price-wise, it offers decent value; just remember that drinks aren’t included, so come prepared for that. The relaxed pace and opportunity to chat with locals and fellow travelers make it a memorable way to spend an evening.

This tour is best suited for adults interested in dark tales and local lore, looking for something different from the typical sightseeing routine. With an engaging guide, a cozy pub environment, and intriguing stories, it provides a balanced mix of entertainment and education — perfect for adding a quirky chapter to your St. Augustine visit.

FAQs

Is this tour suitable for children or under 21?
No, the tour is not suitable for travelers under 21 due to the alcohol-related stops and licensing requirements.

Are drinks included in the tour price?
No, beverages are not included. You’ll purchase your own drinks at each pub, which allows you to choose your favorites and control your budget.

How long does the tour last?
The tour lasts approximately 2 hours, and it involves visiting multiple bars and walking about 0.9 miles in total.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at the Ghost City Tours store at 32 Charlotte St and ends back at the same location.

What should I bring?
You should bring a valid ID or passport, and since recordings are not allowed, it’s best to enjoy the stories with your full attention.

What if it rains?
The tour takes place rain or shine, so dress appropriately and be prepared for outdoor walking and bar visits in any weather.

In the end, if you’re after an evening of chilling stories, historical intrigue, and social fun in St. Augustine, this guided pub crawl offers a memorable way to uncover some of the city’s darker secrets. Just keep your expectations in check — it’s more about the stories and atmosphere than a formal history lesson, making it a fun, quirky addition for the right type of traveler.