Blood On The Cobblestones True Crime Tour of St Augustine

If you’re visiting St. Augustine and looking for an experience that combines a taste of history with a dash of the sinister, the Blood on the Cobblestones tour might just be your perfect evening. This small-group walking adventure offers a compelling look into the city’s darker past, told through vivid stories of murders, mysteries, and unresolved cases. At just $35 per person, it promises a two-hour journey through some of the city’s most haunted and infamous stories, paired with visits to local bars for a bit of refreshment.

What we love about this tour is how the guides bring history alive with engaging storytelling, making the past’s bloodstains feel unexpectedly close. Plus, the route along the oldest streets in the United States offers a historic backdrop that makes each story hit even harder. The chance to visit authentic, locally-owned establishments adds a genuine flavor to the experience. One thing to keep in mind is that alcoholic beverages are not included, so bring some beer money if you want to toast the tales. This tour is best suited for history buffs, true crime fans, or anyone interested in a lively, slightly spooky evening that’s both educational and entertaining.

However, it’s not for everyone—participants must be 21 or older, and the tour involves walking, so be ready for a bit of a stroll. If you’re after a lighthearted ghost tour or family-friendly activity, this one might be too intense. But if you’re eager for stories with a dark twist and a chance to explore St. Augustine’s historic streets after hours, this tour delivers.

Key Points

• Combines chilling true crime stories with visits to local bars in historic St. Augustine
• Focuses on dark chapters of the city’s past, including the oldest unsolved murder in Florida
• Guided by knowledgeable storytellers who keep the stories engaging
• An authentic experience that mixes history, mystery, and local culture
• Ideal for those comfortable with adult themes and walking tours
• Offers great value for the price with detailed storytelling

A Deep Dive into the Tour Experience

What to Expect from the Itinerary

The Blood on the Cobblestones tour unfolds over six stops, each revealing a different story from St. Augustine’s shadowed history. The route takes you through some of the most historic and atmospheric parts of the city, starting on Charlotte Street—an area with roots stretching back to 1785. Here, you’ll hear about the brutal Delany murder, an unsolved case that still echoes through the streets two centuries later. This story sets the tone for the tour: dark, mysterious, and unsolved.

Next, the group visits Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, where the focus shifts to the murder of W.D. Lindsey—an episode soaked in betrayal and south-wide scandal. You’ll enjoy the chance to sip a drink as the story is told, making it a relaxed but intense experience.

The tour continues along Aviles Street, with stories dating back to the 1800s. Here, Juan Carlos’s tale of deceit and deadly consequence offers a glimpse into the city’s layered past. The next stop on Cadiz Street explores the 1974 homicide of Athalia Lindsley—an unsolved mystery that continues to fascinate locals and historians alike.

As you walk along Saint George Street and Cathedral Place, the focus turns to more recent history—specifically the 1990s murder of Amy Blount. This case shook the city, and the storytelling here is particularly poignant, revealing how even small, peaceful towns can harbor dark secrets.

Finally, the tour culminates at Prohibition Kitchen, where you have the opportunity to purchase a drink and reflect on what you’ve learned. The walk is approximately two hours long, with each stop lasting about 20 minutes, allowing plenty of time for stories, photos, and socializing.

What Makes the Stops Special

Charlotte Street feels like stepping into a ghost story set in the late 18th century—imagine the unspoken secrets that still linger in its narrow alleys. The story about the Delany murder is the oldest unsolved case in Florida, which adds historical gravitas to this stop.

Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila offers a cozy, local feel where the storytelling gets a bit more personal. The tale of W.D. Lindsey involves betrayal and scandal, giving insight into the social fabric of the South decades ago.

Aviles Street is the oldest street in the city, and its historic charm adds an eerie backdrop for the Juan Carlos story—highlighting how even trusted community members can turn deadly.

Cadiz Street stands out for its unresolved 1974 murder, which has left many questions unanswered. The fact that no one was convicted keeps this story alive, fueling local speculation.

Saint George Street & Cathedral Place bring you into the 1990s, with a case that shattered the illusion of safety in a city known for its charm. The tragic murder of Amy Blount is a reminder that darkness isn’t just in the past—it can happen anytime.

Prohibition Kitchen makes for a fitting ending, where you can unwind and discuss the stories over a drink, with no pressure to stay or participate.

What the Reviews Say

Multiple reviewers praise the guides’ storytelling skills and knowledge. Comments like “Alisa was a very knowledgeable storyteller” and “Jenna was amazing, funny and very informative,” show that engaging storytelling is a cornerstone of this experience. Many note the stories get better as the tour progresses, which keeps the momentum lively.

Guests also appreciate the balance of history and entertainment. One reviewer mentions how the tour is “a fun night” and “a great change of pace from the usual ghost tours.” The inclusion of local bars with craft cocktails was also highlighted, with some noting the quality of the drinks and the lively atmosphere.

One standout point is the value—at $35, the tour combines storytelling, historic exploration, and socializing, offering a lot for the price. Many reviews mention how the stories are captivating, and the guides keep the group engaged, regardless of weather or group size (which rarely exceeds 25 participants).

Practical Details Matter

The tour is scheduled to run most days, booked on average 17 days in advance, so planning ahead is advisable during peak times. It begins at Ghost City Tours’ meeting point on Charlotte Street, ending at the Prohibition Kitchen on St. George Street—both great locations in the historic district.

Since alcoholic beverages are not included, bringing some beer or a drink of your choice is recommended if you want to toast the tales or simply relax after each story. Remember, this experience is only for those 21 and older, so it’s adult content and atmospherically adult in tone.

The tour’s duration of about two hours makes it a perfect afternoon or evening activity—long enough to tell some compelling stories without feeling rushed. The small-group setting ensures a more intimate and engaging experience, with guides who are committed to bringing the stories to life.

Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?

If you’re into true crime, local history, or just looking for a lively, offbeat way to explore St. Augustine, this tour hits the right notes. The combination of storytelling, historic streets, and local bars creates a memorable and authentic experience. It’s especially good if you enjoy adult-themed stories told by passionate guides who know their stuff.

The price point is fair, considering the storytelling quality and the opportunity to see parts of the city you might not explore on your own. Plus, many reviews highlight the guides’ engaging personalities and depth of knowledge, which make the stories stick long after the tour ends.

However, be prepared for a walking tour with some dark themes—this isn’t a light-hearted ghost walk, but rather a thoughtful look at some of St. Augustine’s most unsettling stories. If you’re comfortable with adult themes and enjoy a good mystery, this experience will likely be a highlight of your trip.

FAQs

Is this tour suitable for children? No, the tour is strictly for guests aged 21 and older due to alcohol consumption and mature themes.

How long does the tour last? The tour is approximately 2 hours, with each of the six stops lasting about 20 minutes.

Are drinks included? No, alcoholic beverages are not included—you’ll need to bring your own beer or purchase drinks at the final stop.

Can I cancel if I change my mind? Yes, cancellations are free if made at least 24 hours before the start time. Cancellations within 24 hours are not refunded.

What’s the meeting point? The tour starts at Ghost City Tours of St. Augustine, located at 32 Charlotte Street, and ends at Prohibition Kitchen on 119 St. George Street.

Is this tour wheelchair accessible? The information doesn’t specify, but since it involves walking along historic streets, accessibility may be limited. It’s best to inquire directly if needed.

To sum it up, the Blood on the Cobblestones tour offers a compelling mix of history, mystery, and local culture, perfect for those who want an adult-oriented night out that’s both educational and entertaining. It’s fun, atmospheric, and well-reviewed—especially thanks to guides who bring the dark tales of St. Augustine vividly to life. Whether you’re a history buff, a true crime fanatic, or just looking for a unique way to explore the city after hours, this experience is worth considering.