New York: Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live

An Insider’s Look at Broadway Comedy Club’s All Star Stand-Up Show in New York City

If you’re visiting New York City and love a good laugh, the Broadway Comedy Club’s All Star Stand-Up Comedy night is an experience worth considering. This 1.5-hour evening features some of the best comedians seen on Comedy Central, HBO, and Saturday Night Live, all performing in a cozy, intimate venue. With tickets priced at just $19, it offers a surprisingly affordable way to enjoy some of NYC’s top comedic talent.

What we particularly like about this show is the close proximity to the stage—every seat provides a clear view of the comedians, making it feel more like sharing a night out with friends rather than a large, impersonal comedy club. The relaxed atmosphere, combined with the opportunity to buy inexpensive drinks during the show, makes for a fun, casual evening.

However, one thing to keep in mind is the two-drink minimum policy—which is standard here, and the drinks can add up, especially if you’re not a big drinker or are on a budget. Plus, some reviews highlight that the show can sometimes run slightly longer than scheduled, so it’s worth planning your evening accordingly.

This experience suits anyone who appreciates stand-up comedy and is eager to see performers who have appeared on TV. It’s also perfect for those looking for an entertaining night out without breaking the bank, especially if you enjoy a lively, intimate setting.

Key Points

• Intimate Venue: All seats are close to the stage, creating a personal comedy experience.
• Top Comedians: Acts are often TV stars from Comedy Central, HBO, SNL, and more.
• Affordable Price: Tickets are just $19, offering excellent value for prime comedy.
• Drinks Required: A 2-drink minimum is enforced—alcoholic or non-alcoholic.
• Flexible Cancellation: Free cancellation up to 24 hours in advance.
• Wheelchair Accessible: The venue accommodates guests with mobility needs.

What to Expect at Broadway Comedy Club

The show is held at the famous Broadway Comedy Club in Times Square, a venue known for nurturing both rising stars and seasoned comedians. Upon arrival, you’ll present your booking confirmation at the box office—early entry (up to 30 minutes before showtime) is encouraged if you want to settle in comfortably.

The lineup features a rotating cast of comedians, with top NYC performers taking center stage. Many have appeared on major comedy platforms, ensuring you’re in for a professional, polished set. Past guests mention that the acts include a mix of established comedians and new talent, which keeps things fresh and lively. Several reviews note that some comedians are still honing their craft, but even those acts can surprise with moments of brilliance.

The show’s duration is approximately 1.5 hours, but it can be 10 minutes longer depending on the lineup and stage interactions. The two-drink minimum policy means you’ll be offered a range of drinks, from soft drinks to cocktails, during the performance. Reviewers have pointed out that drinks can be pricey—Sprite at $9 or mojitos for $16—and that the bill sometimes includes an 18% gratuity automatically added, with extra tip requests afterward. This is typical for NYC venues, but worth noting for budget-conscious travelers.

The Venue and Its Atmosphere

Greenwich Village’s comedy clubs, including Broadway Comedy Club, are renowned for their close-knit, friendly vibe. The venue is designed to foster a more personal interaction between performers and audiences. Unlike larger theaters, here you’ll feel like part of an exclusive comedy night with a small, lively crowd.

Many reviewers mention that the seating is set up facing sideways to the stage, which might be a consideration if you prefer a straightforward view. The intimate setting means you’ll be close enough to see all facial expressions and stage antics clearly.

The Lineup and Performance Quality

The comedians featured are often those who have appeared on MTV, HBO, The Tonight Show, Comedy Central, and other major platforms. This guarantees a level of professionalism and quality that casual comedy nights might lack. Several reviews praise the brilliant comedians, noting some are still new and eager to impress, while others are seasoned performers.

Reviewers consistently mention that the acts are funny, with some noting the variety of humor styles keeps the show engaging. One reviewer appreciated the “cracking set” with comedians “learning their trade,” indicating a good mix of fresh and experienced talent.

That said, some reviews hint at the variability in quality, which is typical in comedy shows with rotating lineups. A few guests found certain acts less funny or harder to follow due to dialects or material. But overall, the consensus is that the majority of comedians deliver and make for a very enjoyable night.

Audience Experience and Tips

Travelers have noted the fun atmosphere—many felt comfortable enough to strike up conversations or chat with their neighbors. The environment is welcoming and suited for couples, groups of friends, or even solo visitors looking for a lively night.

Some reviewers mention that the show ends swiftly—which can feel like a quick, but worthwhile experience. Others appreciated that it’s a very inexpensive way to catch NYC’s best comedians without paying high ticket prices or navigating crowded theaters.

Drinks and Food: What’s Available?

The two-drink minimum policy is standard, and drinks include both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options. While the drinks are generally more expensive than local bars—Sprite costing $9 and cocktails like mojitos around $16—this is typical for NYC. Reviewers have also noted that the quality of drinks varies; some found the cocktails satisfactory, while others thought the options could be better.

Food isn’t included in the ticket price, and the reviews mention that the snack options are limited. The focus is mainly on drinks, so if you’re hungry, it’s wise to eat beforehand or plan to grab a bite after the show.

Practical Details and Making the Most of Your Visit

The tickets are pay later, allowing flexibility for your travel plans—just reserve your spot and settle the bill closer to the date. The venue is wheelchair accessible, ensuring inclusivity for all guests.

The show runs for about 1.5 hours, with a start time you can select based on availability. Arriving 30 minutes early is recommended to get comfortable and settle in. Remember, the automatic gratuity of 18% will most likely be added to your bill, and tipping more is appreciated if you enjoyed the performance.

Since the comedians sometimes ask for extra stage time or drop in unexpectedly, expect some lively interactions. As one reviewer noted, a performer’s set was cut short by a server trying to manage bills—so it’s good to be patient if things are a bit hectic.

Authentic Insights from Reviewers

Many guests highlight that despite the small extras like drink prices or seating arrangements, the overall value for money is high. For $19, you get access to a lineup of comedians who have appeared on major TV shows, making it a steal for comedy fans.

One guest mentioned, “I absolutely loved it and I will definitely come again,” emphasizing how memorable the experience was. Others pointed out the friendly environment and the chance to socialize in a lively, relaxed atmosphere.

However, some reviews expressed concern about the cost of drinks and the fast pace of the show, but these minor drawbacks don’t overshadow the overall enjoyment. Several visitors also appreciated the accessibility and the ease of booking through apps like GetYourGuide.

Who Should Consider This Experience?

This comedy show is best suited for travelers who enjoy stand-up comedy and are looking for a fun, low-cost night out in NYC. It’s ideal for those who appreciate TV comedians and want a more intimate venue experience. The show’s duration and price point make it perfect for a quick evening activity, especially if you’re already in the Times Square area.

It’s also a good choice for solo travelers, couples, or groups who want a relaxed atmosphere where they can chat, laugh, and not worry about large crowds or standing in line.

Those looking for dinner options should plan to eat beforehand or after, as food isn’t a focus here. If you’re sensitive to drinks prices or gratuity policies, be prepared for additional costs beyond your ticket.

Final Thoughts—Is It Worth It?

In terms of value, the Broadway Comedy Club’s All Star Stand-Up show is a cost-effective way to see top-tier comedians in a cozy setting. You’re paying less than the price of a movie ticket for an hour and a half of professional comedy, with the added benefit that you’re closer to the action than in many larger venues.

The fun atmosphere and high-quality acts make it a memorable part of your NYC trip, especially if you’re a comedy enthusiast or just looking for a lively night out. The intimate setup means you’re more than just a face in the crowd—you’re part of the comedy scene for a night.

If you’re okay with the two-drink minimum and are prepared for the occasional variability in the lineup, this experience offers a great way to laugh, relax, and enjoy NYC’s comedy talent without spending a fortune.

FAQ

Is the ticket price all-inclusive?
Yes, the $19 ticket covers your entry. Drinks are extra and subject to the two-drink minimum policy.

Can I cancel my booking?
Yes, you can cancel for a full refund up to 24 hours before the show.

Is the venue wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the venue can accommodate guests with mobility needs.

What should I expect in terms of show duration?
The performance lasts about 1.5 hours, but it could run slightly longer depending on the lineup.

Are children allowed at the show?
No, this experience is not suitable for children under 12.

Do I need to arrive early?
Arriving up to 30 minutes before the show start is recommended to settle in.

Are there food options available?
Food isn’t provided, and the focus is on drinks. It’s best to eat beforehand.

Is the comedy suitable for non-English speakers?
Comedians have diverse dialects, so some material might be harder to follow if English isn’t your first language.

How is the drink quality?
Reviews suggest drinks can vary in quality and are often expensive, so go in knowing the costs are typical for NYC.

Can I expect spontaneous comedy moments?
Yes, comedians sometimes ask for extra stage time or interact with the audience, adding a lively element to the show.

If you’re after a fun, affordable, and authentic NYC comedy experience, the Broadway Comedy Club’s All Star Stand-Up show is a solid choice. Just brace for the drinks bill and enjoy a night of laughs from some of the best comedians around.