NYC: Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos.

If you’re looking for an evening that combines gourmet food, interactive live music, and a dash of exclusivity, this dueling pianos experience in New York City might just be your perfect ticket. Offered at a renowned steak and seafood restaurant, this event promises an energetic, sing-along night that’s as much about the ambiance as the entertainment.

What makes this tour stand out? First, it’s the longest-running dueling pianos show in NYC, a testament to its popularity and staying power. Second, the venue itself — tucked away in a secret underground showroom within the Hunt and Fish Club — adds a sense of mystery and exclusiveness. A potential downside? Because it’s a ticketed, seated event with a minimum food and beverage spend, it’s best suited for those who are ready to indulge a bit.

This experience is ideal for couples, groups of friends, or anyone eager to enjoy a lively, music-filled night out paired with some of the city’s best steak and seafood. If you value interactive entertainment and a cozy, upscale setting, then this could turn into a memorable highlight of your NYC visit.

Key Points

• Exclusive underground venue within a top NYC steakhouse offers a unique, intimate setting.
• Huge song selection ensures no two shows are alike; you’ll find your favorites and discover new tunes.
• High-quality food and drinks include crafted cocktails, designer burgers, and the restaurant’s famous bread.
• Affordable price point at $59 per person, which includes a four-hour experience with table reservations.
• Minimum spend requirement of $40 per guest on food and beverages, plus a 20% service charge.
• Ideal for music lovers and foodies seeking an interactive, lively evening with a touch of exclusivity.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Introduction: A Night of Fine Food and Live Music in the City That Never Sleeps

Imagine a night out where you not only dine on some of NYC’s finest steak and seafood but also sing your heart out at a world-class dueling pianos show. This experience, hosted at the Hunt and Fish Club — an acclaimed restaurant inside the AKA Times Square Hotel — combines upscale dining with interactive entertainment in a secret, underground setting. It’s a rare chance to enjoy a long-standing New York tradition that’s been delighting audiences for years.

Two aspects we especially appreciate are the variety of songs available — with thousands of options ensuring a different night every time — and the craftsmanship of the food, from their famous bread to their signature cocktails. However, one consideration is that the ticket price doesn’t include food or drinks; there’s a $40 minimum spend per person, which might be a surprise if you’re expecting an all-inclusive package. Still, the overall value is compelling for those wanting a top-tier show paired with quality dining.

This experience caters best to those who love interactive music, enjoy upscale dining, and appreciate authentic live entertainment. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a fun night out, this tour offers a distinctive slice of NYC nightlife.

What Makes This Experience Special?

The Dueling Pianos Show — A Unique Form of Entertainment

The core of this experience is the dueling pianos performance, which claims to be the best in the USA. The performers are talented, engaging musicians who take requests from the audience, making every show personal and unpredictable. We loved the way the performers encourage sing-alongs and laughter, creating a lively, communal atmosphere. As one review put it, “It’s not just a concert — it’s a full-on party.”

The show’s long history — the longest-running dueling pianos in New York City — adds to its credibility. You’re not just catching a touristy act; you’re experiencing a trusted, well-loved tradition that has evolved over years. Each night is different, thanks to the vast song library — thousands of tunes spanning rock, pop, classic hits, and more — ensuring that everyone from Sinatra fans to 2000s pop enthusiasts feels right at home.

The Venue — An Intimate, Secret Underground Setting

Most people love the concealed location of the event. Inside the Hunt and Fish Club, the event takes place in a private, underground showroom. This cozy, intimate environment enhances the sense of exclusivity, making it feel like a special event rather than just another dinner.

The seating is reserved at 7 pm, with the show kicking off at 8:30 pm. This timing allows guests to enjoy a relaxed dinner beforehand. With only 50 tickets available each night, it’s a more personal experience, avoiding the crowded feel of larger venues.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Food — Gourmet, Fun, and Well-Reviewed

While the main focus is the entertainment, the restaurant’s reputation for excellent cuisine shouldn’t be overlooked. The menu features designer burgers, seafood, and their famous bread, which many reviews rave about. The restaurant takes pride in offering crafted cocktails that complement the lively atmosphere.

The $40 food and beverage minimum means you’ll be indulging in drinks and dishes, making the overall cost higher than just the ticket price. But considering the quality of the food and the experience, many find it to be good value. The service charge of 20% is standard in upscale NYC restaurants, so plan your budget accordingly.

What to Expect During the Night

Arrival and Seating

Guests check in at the host stand and are given reserved table seating. Early arrival at 7 pm ensures you get a good spot, closer to the performers and the action. The atmosphere is relaxed but lively, with guests eager to kick off an evening of fun.

The Show — An All-Request Live Music Party

The performance begins at 8:30 pm, after dinner service has started to wind down. The dueling pianos are the stars, each playing and singing requests from the audience. Expect a rock ‘n’ roll party that’s interactive and engaging. As one reviewer states, “The performers really get the crowd involved, making it feel like a private party.”

The song library is extensive, so don’t hesitate to ask for your favorite tunes. The performers also laugh, joke, and encourage audience participation, creating a jovial, relaxed vibe.

Food & Drink — An Integral Part of the Night

The menu includes famous bread, designer burgers, and an array of cocktails crafted for a lively, celebratory mood. Keep in mind the $40 minimum spend; many guests find that ordering a few drinks and sharing dishes enhances the experience. Service charges are added onsite, so budget accordingly.

Ending the Night

The show wraps around 11 pm, giving you several hours of entertainment and dining. It’s a great option if you’re looking for something more dynamic than a traditional dinner show or a typical night out in Times Square.

Authentic Perspectives and Review Highlights

Multiple reviews praise the friendly, talented performers and the well-curated song list. One guest mentioned, “The whole night felt like a private concert with friends,” emphasizing the personal touch of the event. Others highlight the quality of the food and the cozy ambiance as significant draws.

Some note that ticket availability is limited — only 50 tickets per night — so booking in advance is wise, especially if you’re coming during peak tourist seasons. A few reviews mention that the minimum spend can seem a bit high for some, but they generally agree that the overall experience justifies the cost.

Practical Details

Price and Value

At $59 per person, this experience offers good value considering the length (4 hours), the premium entertainment, and the upscale setting. The $40 minimum on food and drinks pushes the total closer to $100 per person, but many guests find the quality and atmosphere make it worth the extra spend.

Location and Accessibility

Located at 125 W 44th St inside the AKA Times Square Hotel, it’s easily accessible from most parts of Manhattan. Check-in is straightforward, and the venue’s reserved seating ensures a comfortable night.

Timing and Group Size

The event generally runs in the evening, with a 4-hour duration. Because of the limited tickets, it’s a more intimate experience, perfect for smaller groups or couples wanting a more personal feel.

Cancellation & Flexibility

Tickets are fully refundable if canceled up to 24 hours in advance, giving you peace of mind if your plans change.

Who Would Love This Experience?

This tour is ideal for music lovers of all ages who enjoy engaging, interactive performances. It’s also perfect for foodies who want a memorable dinner in a refined environment. Couples celebrating a special night, groups of friends looking for lively entertainment, or even solo travelers eager for a fun, energetic evening will find this experience rewarding.

Those expecting a formal concert might be surprised by the party atmosphere — it’s lively, loud, and participatory. It’s less about a polished show and more about having fun and making memories.

The Sum Up

This NYC dueling pianos experience offers a rare blend of top-tier entertainment, quality food, and a cozy, exclusive setting. For around $60, you’re not only getting a four-hour lively performance but also the chance to sing along with talented performers in a hidden underground venue. The event’s long-standing reputation and enthusiastic reviews suggest it truly delivers on its promise of a memorable night.

It’s best suited for adults who love music, laughter, and a touch of sophistication. If you’re after a dynamic, interactive evening that combines great food with great fun, this is a fantastic pick. Just remember to book ahead, budget for drinks and tips, and prepare for a night that’s sure to be a highlight of your NYC trip.

FAQ

Is this experience suitable for children?
No, it’s not recommended for children under 16 due to the lively, adult-oriented atmosphere and alcohol service.

How do I secure my tickets?
Tickets are held under your name at will call. Since only 50 tickets are available per night, advanced booking is highly recommended.

What is included in the ticket price?
The ticket covers the 4-hour dueling pianos show and reserved table seating. Food and drinks are not included but require a $40 minimum per guest.

Can I request specific songs?
Yes, part of the fun is requesting your favorite songs. The performers take audience requests, making each show unique.

When should I arrive?
Guests are seated at 7 pm, with the show starting at 8:30 pm, so arriving early ensures good seats and ample time to enjoy your meal.

What is the dress code?
While not explicitly stated, the venue’s reputation and setting suggest a smart casual dress is appropriate.

Is there a way to cancel if my plans change?
Yes, tickets can be canceled up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, offering flexibility in your planning.

This experience combines the thrill of live music, delicious, upscale dining, and an air of exclusivity — a night out that’s both memorable and uniquely New York. Whether celebrating, entertaining friends, or simply seeking a lively night, it’s worth considering for your visit.

You can check availability for your dates here: More Great Tours Nearby