10:30pm Shadows of the Supernatural Tour

If you’re looking for a nighttime adventure that offers more than just ghost stories, the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour in St. Augustine is worth considering. This 90-minute journey takes you through some of the city’s most intriguing cemeteries and historic sites, all backed by thorough research and real paranormal evidence. It’s not just about whispering legends — it’s about stories rooted in fact, augmented by photos, recordings, and personal experiences shared by guides who genuinely seem invested in their craft.

What we love about this tour is its focus on authenticity. Unlike many ghost tours that rely on urban legend and exaggerated tales, this experience emphasizes true stories and documented investigations. Plus, the late-night timing adds a layer of thrill, making it perfect for night owls or those who prefer their spooky encounters after sunset. That said, it’s worth noting that the group size remains small—maxing out at 30—ensuring a more intimate and engaging atmosphere. If you’re open to a mix of history, ghostly evidence, and a dash of adrenaline, this tour is likely to suit your interests well.

One thing to consider is the price. At $25 per person, the tour offers solid value, especially given the depth of information and evidence presented. Still, it’s not a traditional ghost walk filled with urban legends; it’s a research-backed exploration of haunted sites, which might appeal more to those who enjoy factual stories and investigative evidence rather than purely spooky tales.

This tour is best suited for travelers curious about genuine paranormal investigations, history buffs interested in the darker side of St. Augustine, or anyone seeking a fun, slightly eerie evening with knowledgeable guides.

Key Points

• Focus on authentic haunted sites with researched history and real paranormal evidence
• Tour includes visits to cemeteries, historic buildings, and the oldest wooden school house
• Guides share personal paranormal experiences, photos, and recordings
• Duration is approximately 1.5 hours, making it a manageable evening activity
• Small group size enhances the experience and allows for interaction
• Good value for the price, especially considering the evidence shared and storytelling depth

A Closer Look at the Experience

The Shadows of the Supernatural Tour kicks off at A1A Ale Works on King Street, a convenient meeting point in the heart of St. Augustine. From there, the route covers a series of historically significant and supposedly haunted sites, finishing at the Prince Murat House on St. George Street. The tour is designed to be both entertaining and educational, blending factual history with evidence of paranormal activity.

The Stops in Detail

Tolomato Cemetery — We start at this historic graveyard, which is known for its haunted reputation. Your guide shares stories about its ghostly past, supported by paranormal evidence captured there. Expect a lively discussion about spirit sightings and unusual recordings. With just about 10 minutes here, it’s enough to set a spooky tone without lingering too long.

Potter’s Wax Museum — Moving next to this iconic building, the guide describes its haunted history and shares evidence from investigations. The museum’s long history makes it ripe for ghost stories, and the paranormal evidence presented offers a glimpse into what investigators have uncovered. This stop also provides a visual break with the wax figures, adding a slightly eerie charm.

38 Cordova Street — Here, the tour highlights the story of a little ghost girl haunting the Memories Room. The guide recounts paranormal evidence collected during investigations, making it a compelling stop for those interested in entity encounters with children or small spirits. Ten minutes is enough to weave a haunting tale with supporting evidence.

Casablanca Inn on the Bay — This beautiful inn has a haunted reputation tied to architect Goold Butler. Your guide shares stories about his spirit and evidence collected on site. This stop gives a mix of historic elegance and ghostly activity, enriching the tour’s narrative.

Oldest Wooden School House — One of the most iconic haunted spots, this historic school is said to be haunted by ghost children. The guide discusses the building’s past and paranormal findings, giving visitors a chance to imagine what it was like to be a student in a haunted classroom.

Prince Murat House — The journey concludes at this historic residence, famous for the spirit of Faye Sheldon. The guide shares her story, along with paranormal evidence, wrapping up the tour on a spooky but respectful note.

The Guides and Their Approach

According to reviews, guides like Bill and Tim are praised for their knowledge and engaging storytelling. Many guests mention their enthusiasm, clarity, and ability to blend history with paranormal evidence seamlessly. This approach makes the tour accessible and interesting, even for skeptics or those less familiar with ghost lore.

What’s Included

The tour features a focus on research-backed stories, with evidence like photos and recordings shown during stops. The guide’s personal paranormal experiences enhance credibility and keep the atmosphere lively. The tour runs at night, which not only heightens the spooky vibe but also offers unique views of the city’s illuminated historic sites.

Practical Considerations

This experience is suitable for most travelers; service animals are permitted, and the group size is kept small for a more personalized experience. The tour operates rain or shine, but poor weather may cause cancellations, with full refunds offered if that happens.

The price point is reasonable, especially considering the depth of storytelling and the evidence shared. The tour is booked about 11 days in advance on average, indicating good demand and popularity.

Authentic Paranormal Evidence and Personal Stories

One of the standout aspects of this tour is the presentation of paranormal evidence. Guests report seeing photos and recordings that support the ghost stories — an unusual feature for a tour at this price point. This evidence, combined with the guide’s recounting of personal experiences, gives the stories a sense of authenticity.

“Bill was an awesome guide,” says one reviewer, emphasizing his knowledge and ability to make the tour exciting. Others mention how the evidence captivated them and added credibility to the stories, making the experience more than just a collection of spooky tales.

The Balance of History and Haunting

While ghost stories are central, the tour’s foundation is historical. Guests learn about the backgrounds of the sites and their significance, which adds depth. This mix appeals to those who enjoy learning about a city’s darker corners without feeling they’re just being spun urban legends.

Nighttime Atmosphere

The late start at 10:30 pm adds an extra layer of authenticity. Walking through historic sites under the night sky, with fewer crowds, enhances the sense of mystery. The quiet of the night makes the paranormal evidence and stories more immersive.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This experience fits best for travelers interested in history, paranormal investigations, or simply seeking a different way to explore St. Augustine after dark. It caters to those who appreciate well-researched stories and authentic evidence, rather than ghostly exaggerations. It’s also suitable for small groups seeking an intimate, informative experience.

People who enjoy a bit of suspense but prefer factual storytelling over urban legend will find this tour engaging. On the other hand, if you’re solely looking for a scare or are skeptical about paranormal claims, you might find it less thrilling.

Final Thoughts on Value and Experience

At $25 per person, the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour offers a compelling blend of history and haunting, backed by evidence and authentic stories. The tour’s strength lies in its well-researched approach and the guide’s ability to make each stop come alive with genuine paranormal investigations. It’s a good choice for those who want a spooky night that feels credible and interesting, rather than purely theatrical.

The small group size and the opportunity to see a different side of St. Augustine make it a memorable addition to your evening plans. It’s especially appealing for visitors who enjoy a mix of learning and mystery, with enough evidence to satisfy believers and skeptics alike.

In short, this tour is a well-rounded, engaging way to experience St. Augustine’s haunted past—perfect for curious travelers, history buffs, and ghost enthusiasts.

FAQ

Is the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour suitable for children?
Most travelers can participate, and the tour’s content is generally appropriate for older children. However, it’s best to consider your child’s comfort with spooky stories and late-night walks.

How long is the tour?
It lasts about 1 hour and 30 minutes, making it a manageable activity for an evening outing.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom on King Street and ends at the Prince Murat House on St. George Street, both central locations in St. Augustine.

Is there an age limit or group size restriction?
Most travelers can join, with a maximum of 30 in the group, which helps keep the experience more personal and engaging.

Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, it is recommended to book about 11 days ahead since it’s popular, and tickets are mobile for convenience.

What is included in the tour?
The tour features researched stories, paranormal evidence (photos, recordings), and personal paranormal experiences shared by the guide.

What if the weather is bad?
The tour is weather-dependent; if canceled due to poor conditions, you will be offered a different date or a full refund.

In the end, this experience offers a thoughtful, credible look at St. Augustine’s haunted sites. It’s perfect for those who want a late-night adventure with a good dose of history and real paranormal evidence — a memorable way to see a different side of this historic city.